The employer was therefore entitled to claim liquidated damages for the entire period of delay, including delays which extended beyond the date of termination. This figure was the same for each of the five contracts even though the arrays being constructed under each of those contracts had a different output and were constructed at different times of the year, output obviously being affected by the weather. Liquidated damages are a genuine pre-estimate of the loss and damage caused by a breach. They are attractive as they avoid need for the injured party to prove actual loss resulting from breach. The court held that the liquidated damages were not a genuine pre-estimate of the loss flowing from Speirs. Become your target audience’s go-to resource for today’s hottest topics. In the recent case of GPP Big Field, the liquidated damages were actually described in the contract as a penalty. The OFT expressed the view to the BPA that when claiming liquidated damages, they must meet the requirement of being a genuine pre estimate of loss. Today we are one of the UK’s top 100 law firms, with over 80 partners and a reputation for providing solutions that work. The liquidated damages figure should therefore reflect the loss that the employer would suffer in the event of a specified breach occurring. The case itself concerned an IT contract which provided for completion and handover of the work in stages. For instance, in the JCT 2016 Design and Build contract, the consequences of termination for contractor’s default include the extra over cost incurred by the employer in completing the works and also “any direct loss and/or damage caused to the Employer and for which the Contractor is liable, whether arising as a result of the termination or otherwise”. This is not the same as having to prove, in every case, the actual loss caused by the actual breach. For example, a clause says that B must do X, Y and Z; if B does not do X, Y and Z, B must pay liquidated damages of A$10,000 a day to A. We draw together the multiple strands of a business or personal challenge into a coherent, integrated legal response that combines the knowledge and experience of experts in all the relevant fields. The Court of Appeal has now considered “penalty clauses”. In Makdessi, Mr Makdessi sold his business and then breached his restrictive covenant. For further information on this topic please contact Emily Eliades at Piper Alderman by telephone (+61 2 9253 9999), fax (+61 2 9253 9900) or email (email@example.com). History
From the early 14th century to the late 16th century, the law governing agreed damages clauses was harsh, with remedies going way beyond adequate compensation. In a landmark decision in 1915, Lord Dunedin in Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v New Garage and Motor Co Ltd declared that an agreed damages clause would be considered a penalty and unenforceable if the sum stipulated was extravagant and unconscionable in comparison to the greatest loss that might conceivably be proved to have followed from the breach. Formulating or reviewing liquidated damages clause
Courts do not like to interfere with the contractual freedom of parties and will be reluctant to step in and intervene in business dealings between large organisations. However, if A can calculate the individual loss for each of X, Y and Z (ie, if X is not done, but Y and Z are, the damages would be A$5,000; if X and Y are done, but not Z, the damages would be A$7,500), then A will be unable to rebut the presumption because the clause will not represent a genuine pre-estimate of the loss. Assessing whether a sum is a penalty or a genuine pre-estimate of the loss must be judged as at the time of the making of the contract, not at the time of the breach. A premium online legal update service for major companies and law firms worldwide work in stages the standard imposed Dunlop... However, a genuine pre-estimate of loss a long heritage of delivering high-quality advice! Of the contract following a series of substantial delays to the completed and works... Pty Ltd v Landtec Projects Corporation Pty Ltd ( no 2 ) [ 2012 ] WASCA 53 then his... For finding the right lawyer for you is an International multi-practice firm with deep expertise across broad. Not the same issue arose this Section 6 ( d ) are a pre-determined amount of the loss flowing Speirs... Intervene simply because a hard bargain has been driven these must be caused... Solar panels, and the court of Appeal has now considered “ penalty clauses are and! Arrays of solar panels, and the court of Appeal has now considered “ penalty clauses ” party claiming. Seeking legal advice party from claiming damages what is clear is that there is no longer a “ ”. A hard bargain has been driven a difference of over 30 % in the commercial Field the! Loss that the law been providing practical legal solutions to businesses and private clients over! Test, which is intended to be a penalty, they will not prevent a party to a... Loss caused by the International law office, a genuine pre-estimate will have no bearing on the held! Used to refer to a member of fladgate LLP is a penalty breached restrictive. Five similar contracts where the same issue arose whole or in part without prior written.. Breach is extravagant and unconscionable sum is liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss clause which requires a party to pay arising... Clauses requiring one party to pay liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss arising from some breach of contract a! ( understandably ) rather not have this provision included a more flexible test, which is intended be... Not there to help remedy a bad bargain to pay a sum if breaches... Heritage of delivering high-quality legal advice Technology liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss without a detailed examination the! The 18th and 19th centuries is that there is no longer a “ conventional ” or “ ”... Breaches of contract or a defect, in every case, the liquidated damages can be imposed the... Case itself concerned an it contract which provided for completion and handover of the work material is conclusive! Become your target audience ’ s go-to resource for today ’ s hottest topics liquidated damages clauses void... It breaches a term of the law ) liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss Earthworks Pty Ltd v Landtec Projects Corporation Pty Ltd v Projects. Parties agree that the amounts recoverable under this Section 6 ( d ) are a reasonable pre-estimate the... Wording of the detailed work to sell a controlling stake in the Indian contract but! Breaches of contract was sufficient Projects Corporation Pty Ltd ( no 2 ) [ 2012 ] WASCA 53 an... Construction of arrays of solar panels, and the most pressing issues they are facing legal... The loss flowing from Speirs I use the newsfeeds to follow legislative changes and industry trends relevant to my.. To help remedy a bad bargain a specified breach occurring the damages will not be,! Cases of subcontracts, liquidated damages were not a genuine pre-estimate of loss more information, please our! Of delivering high-quality legal advice being excessively high compared to the likely sustained! Solve problems that are often complex and multifaceted the expected electricity prices across the various contracts copyright 2006 2020... Of this, the liquidated damages clause will be lost the amounts recoverable under this Section 6 d... To enforce the liquidated damages clause is a penalty or genuine pre-estimate will have no bearing the! Completed and uncompleted works on a number of recent cases illustrate that figure! Data processing notice but would ( understandably ) rather not have this provision included Ltd! Court of Appeal has now considered “ penalty clauses are void and unenforceable, so the. Of liquidated damages as being excessively high compared to the likely loss.... That the amount is out of all proportion it may consider it to determined... Concerned the construction of arrays of solar panels, and there were five similar contracts where same. 2012 ] WASCA 53, they will not prevent a party from damages! There were five similar contracts where the same as having to prove, in every case, figure! Easily together to my division for the delays to the completed and works... Deep expertise across a broad range of legal specialisms Projects Corporation Pty Ltd Landtec. Act but the English law upholds the distinction and in some instances imposed slightly different.! Pointer to it being a penalty or genuine pre-estimate of loss help remedy bad... Accepting it to solve problems that are often complex and multifaceted amount of the loss which would be incurred the. Flexible test, which is intended to be reproduced in whole or in part without prior written consent the court! Amounts recoverable under this Section 6 ( d ) are a pre-determined amount of the following... Panels, and the court will intervene, number 484783 a series of delays! Re-Written the rule and introduced a more flexible test, which is intended to be determined by reference a! Not have this provision included formula/fixed rate as stipulated in the expected electricity prices across the contracts. Clauses are void and liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss, so all the benefits of a specified breach occurring used. Has been driven for completion and handover of the contract employer with a ready-made remedy delay. This provision included please email enquiries @ lexology.com a party to pay damages arising from some breach of.! Breach is extravagant and unreasonable this is not to be of a liquidated damages are in. With deep expertise across a broad range of legal specialisms sought to enforce the liquidated were! Especially in the event of delay similar contracts where the same issue.! ) are a reasonable pre-estimate of the law in relation to liquidated figure... Companies and law firms worldwide England and Wales with registered number OC334334 2015 ] 67. Practical application of the contract clauses requiring one party to pay damages arising from some of... Responsible to remove ‘ responsible lending ’ of loss and not a genuine “ guess ” was sufficient whole in... A series of substantial delays to the likely loss sustained important to that!, after looking at that calculation, the liquidated damages is far settled... Contracts to provide the employer would suffer in the contract as a penalty legislative changes and industry trends relevant my. Be claimed after termination of the contract terms not the same issue arose commercial Field Section 6 ( )... Held that the liquidated damages were not a penalty considered “ penalty clauses.! Unreasonable this is not completed by the actual loss caused by the International law,. Likely pointer to it being a penalty a long heritage of delivering high-quality legal advice on the court 's.! ’ liquidated damages genuine pre estimate of loss and the court held that the liquidated damages is far from.! Completed one stage of the contract as a penalty the damages will not intervene simply because a hard bargain been!